OK. So things are a bit scary right now. In addition to the stuff I'm seeing on the news about the alt-right shit already starting, I got a lovely letter from the girls' school superintendent saying, yeah, hate crime is up in our county and in our schools specifically. Gee. Great. Tell me again how I'm being a whiny baby because I'm upset about the election.
Anyway, so I am totally and completely recognizing your fears right now. I know that belly grabbing worry. As long as they are still in you, you can protect them and shield them from everything, but what kind of world are they going to be born into? What kind of world do they get to grow up in? Is this really a turning point for our country or is it just hormones blowing everything out of proportion? Trust me. I'm right there with you.
total innocence
Here's what I decided, though, as I hugged my own little baby at 2:00 am. I was looking at her perfect little face and worrying about what kind of hate she would encounter as she got older. Her big sisters already have plenty of stories of hate from their peers, and after listening to the oldest tell me her fears as she recounted MORE stories of escalating hate speech, I was nearly in tears. My daughters are the most wonderful people I know. I don't want other people not seeing that. Then I realized the obvious. Other mothers and fathers and parent figures around the country were probably staring at their perfect babies and thinking the same thing. So what if I make sure that my baby grows up to be the antidote? I can do that. I can teach her to see the good and not be a racist asshat. I can teach her that immigrants are cool (her dad's one, so that makes that lesson easy). I can teach her that gender doesn't limit her. I can teach her that families come in all shapes and sizes and styles. I can teach her that love is love. We need a hero. Why can't Sally be that hero?
Even if she doesn't lead a massive cultural revolution some day (or fly around in a cool robot suit), chances are in her own small way she will spread love to the people immediately around her. Even if that is all, that is big. She will be part of the solution. If all of us hugging our precious babies or rubbing our growing bellies decided to be fighters and raise our children to love instead of melting into puddles of despair, think of how that will affect our country. Someone else's kid will have an ally. Someone else's kid will not feel like the whole world is against them because there will be that one light, smiling across the classroom.
So don't freak out just yet. You are powerful. You are growing a powerful person. What we need is a hero and you will give birth to one. You can do this. And in taking on this mission, you will feel stronger and braver. You will have a definite purpose and a willing partner (babies love love). And you will not be alone. Over here, I will be on the same mission raising my own little heroes.
Super Heroes assembling and plotting their next adventure.
I have not really said much about the election since
Tuesday. My quiet has been for two reasons. One, I have been struggling to put
into words the anxiety and disappointment I have been feeling, and, two, I have
been too disgusted by the total lack of empathy which I have seen displayed
time and again. What’s the point of saying how my family and I feel if no one
can look beyond their own noses? I have only lasted a minute at a time checking
facebook because it doesn’t take long to get to the person calling us crybabies
or saying those of us who are upset need to grow up. Seriously? After eight
years of listening to people say about President Obama “Not My President” and
insulting him and calling him a terrorist dictator anti-Christ, we can’t have
even one day to be upset about Trump winning? If you are actually interested in
thinking about this situation from a viewpoint other than suburban white Christian
heterosexual, here is why I am upset.
I’m not mad that my candidate lost (even though she did get
the most votes and the whole electoral college thing is dumb, and even Trump
was agreeing with that before the election and people from both sides in the
past have said this system is messed up). I’m frightened that
Trump and Pence won. To say that he is just another candidate or that the
choice was simply between the lesser of two evils is to live under a privileged
rock. What they want to do, and what Pence has already done in Indiana, is going to hurt a lot of people. They
already have hurt a lot of people. Don’t believe me? OPEN YOUR DAMN EYES. Sorry
for yelling, but talking hasn’t seemed to get people to see things.
Know what conversation I have with my daughter every day?
“Will Trump send Tato back?”
“No, honey. Tato is a US citizen. He
can’t be deported.”
“But Trump wants to? What about my
friends? Will they be sent back?”
Then I have to explain the logistics of mass deportation and
why it is highly unlikely. She still comes back round to, “but they want to do
it.” That hurts. And we aren’t having this conversation daily because I am a
bad mom who over exposes my kids to the news. This is what they have been
talking about on the playgrounds since Trump first started his campaign based
on racism, and on the playground they aren’t thinking in terms of logistics or
constitutional law. They are thinking about their families and their friends.
They aren’t thinking “it’s ok because my dad is white and he is only talking
about Muslims and Mexicans” because they aren’t that fucking racist. If someone
says immigrant they think of their dad and their neighbors. They think of our
friends who are refugees. They think of their relatives still living outside
this country and wondering if they will be allowed to visit. Do you have any
idea how much anxiety this causes? Do you have any idea what kind of affect
that anxiety has on them? Are you willing to even try?
People say, “oh you should just explain things to them and
not let them listen to Trump.” Two problems with that. First, I have explained
things but the fear is brought up again day after day as the same hateful
rhetoric is repeated. Second, I do try to shield them from Trump, but he isn’t
the only one saying this stuff. His followers and apologists are saying it. The alt-right is gleefully shouting it now that they feel validated by our President-elect. Are you
saying for the next four years I can’t let my girls listen to their President? Forcing
them to hide their heads in the sand will not help.
As for us overreacting or predicting disaster before it
hits, it has already hit. Hate crimes against Muslims is up.
Hate crimes against the LGBTQ community is up. Anti-Semitic rhetoric is up.
People are being threatened. People ARE being attacked. The fear is justified.
Do you know what that fear looks like in a little girl? She stops eating. She
complains she can’t breath. She starts compulsively chewing on her lip. She
doesn’t want to go to school. This is a real problem not an imaginary one. She
has seen and heard and physically felt the increase in attacks as people feel
emboldened to share their hate. When the top leader of our country and his
sidekick are spewing hate, of course the lower haters feel validated and
empowered. That is then manifested even in middle schools.
I won’t even get into the misogyny stuff or violence against
women or threats against the press (my husband is a journalist, so these threats I take VERY seriously). If you can’t see the racism manifesting or empathize with the victims of
homophobia and Islamaphobia, then I’m not holding out hope here either.
To say we have to be ok with all this or that it isn’t so
bad or that we need to get over it IS condoning it. It makes you an accessory
to hate. Sure you won’t personally be burning Pride flags or beating Hispanic
homeless men to death, but you are allowing it to happen by looking the other way. You are saying there is
nothing wrong with it happening. You are saying you don’t care about the
suffering of other people. You are saying you don’t care about my family or our
closest friends. You are name calling the people being punched when they crying out.
I don’t unfriend people for political differences. I think
political discourse is good. In the past, however, it has been about
differences of opinion regarding the details of policies. We have been heading
towards the same goal but discussing different paths. That discourse has helped
us think more broadly. Now, though, what I see is a total lack of empathy. That
is something I have been struggling to accept. How can these people who say
they love my daughters also say they don’t care about them? We are just trying
to wrap our heads around what the future will be and come up with ways to
survive our new hostile America.
What we need is hugs not “oh, grow up!” While I try to figure out what to do
about all this, I think I better just stay away from facebook. Until I can
decide how to handle friends being ok with people hurting my kids, I better
just not handle them at all. Otherwise I will soon just start unfriending
people or screaming “FUCK YOU” at them. Until this mama bear can CTFD (as I
have been told to do by people who claim they didn’t vote for Trump but they
don’t think he or Pence are that bad), I will just live in my real world. My
daughters are going to be needing my extra attention now anyway.
School has started up again which means after school
conversations are starting up again. Don’t get me wrong; I talk to my girls all
year, not just after school. Our after school chats, however, are extra
important and why I’m glad I have a schedule that allows me to take that time
with them.
You know in the movie Tinkerbell when she is going through
the various talents to find hers? (If you don’t know what I am talking about,
ask a preschooler or click here.) Well, if I were a fairy the talent that would
have lit up and sent a shock wave around would be the talking talent. I’m a
talker-fairy which is good because that was my job for years as a retreat
leader. I got paid to talk to people – lots of people – and listen to their
stories. It was perfect and great prep for being a mom now.
The fact is talk saves lives. That isn’t being hyperbolic.
It is true. We must talk and connect. We must be aware of what is happening in
the lives and minds of the people around us. We must talk with our children to
help them understand their lives and minds. We must talk through problems to
find realistic solutions and create actions plans. And we must talk with our
children to affirm and reaffirm and reaffirm again their value as intelligent,
amazing human beings. It’s important stuff.
I know from watching others come in and struggle with
leading small groups that this isn’t a skill that everyone comes to naturally.
I also know from listening to the teens that this isn’t something that all
parents seem to be doing, or at least aren’t doing well. I wonder if it is
because parents, like adults thrown into leading small groups of teens without
any training, aren’t sure where to begin or how to do it. So here are my top
tips for starting those conversations, keeping them going, and getting the most
out of them so more and more adults can build meaningful connections with the
kids and teens (and other adults) in their lives.
Turn off the tv, computer, whatever
screen is near you, and keep your phone put away. Have you ever tried
having a conversation with someone who was looking at a screen instead of
you? Did you really think you had their full attention? When we look at
screens instead of the people we are with, we are nonverbally saying,
“yeah, you’re important, but not interesting enough to drag me away from
this more interesting thing.” Don’t think kids and teens pick up on that?
They do. Just ask them.
Stop multitasking all together.
Again, this is about showing the person you are talking to that that
person is the most important thing in your life at that moment. Chatting
while doing dishes or driving or vacuuming (if you can even hear each
other) is fine for light conversations, but for real, deep connecting
conversations stop everything else. Let your kid know he or she is the
single most important thing in your life and give him or her your full,
total, complete, nondistracted attention. The dishes can wait.
Giving the girls our full attention. listening to how life's going.
Be genuine and 100% honest. Kids
can smell a phony a mile away, and teens hate hypocrites and fakers. Once
they think you are lying or putting on an act, you will have to work VERY
hard to regain their trust. You want them to be honest with you? Be honest
with them. Does this mean confessing all your sins in graphic detail or
disclosing information about their emotional processing level? Of course
not. What you do say, say truthfully. You don’t like broccoli? Say that!
“I don’t really like broccoli, but I eat it because I know it is important
for me to get vitamins and minerals from multiple food sources. It isn’t
enjoyable, but the result of being healthy I do like.” If they pick up you
are being honest, your words will carry more weight.
Be open. One thing I discovered
quickly as a retreat leader was that for every ounce of my story I shared,
I got a pound of the teens’ stories in return. Once I showed that I was
open enough to tell them things about me, they felt more comfortable
sharing their stories with me. I usually had to go first, as an ice
breaker. This means I need to be comfortable with my story, and I am very
selective about what parts I tell and limit details as needed, but usually
the details are less important than the act of sharing at all. An example
would be telling about your experience with your fifth grade teacher.Then wait and see if they share
their experience. If they don’t, gently prompt. To listen, first we have
to talk sometimes.
Open ended questions are the best
prompts. Ask more specific things and follow them up with more
questions. Follow up questions are key to getting to the heart of the matter.
It’s unlikely I’ll ever get the full story from one question. I keep
digging and never lose eye contact. Show them you really are interested
and care about their stories. Keep digging! The simplest follow up is
“why?” Just be sure to be clear with your questions. “Why do you think
your teacher called on you less than the other kids?” “Why did you choose
to play with those kids today instead of your usual crowd?” “Why do you
think the principal made that a rule?”
Acknowledge –without judgment – their feelings. Whether or not you think
their feelings are rational or the feelings you would have, if they voice
those as the emotions they are experiencing, those are the feelings they
have. Repeat them back to let them know you heard them. “You’re feeling angry
and frustrated because your whole class was punished for a few kids
talking in the hall.” When our feelings are acknowledged, we feel
empowered to express more which just leads to better mental health. It
also helps us feel closer to the person we are talking to. Once those
emotions are disregarded, the kid or teen who expressed them will shut
down and not feel comfortable sharing more. That leads to a dark place of
bottling up feelings which is not healthy for anyone of any age or gender.
Finally, work TOGETHER to create an
action plan if one is needed. Sometimes chat sessions are more about
touching base or venting. Sometimes, though, change is needed. Rather than
lecture (another way to shut down communication), say, “let’s find a
solution together.” Listen to
their thoughts about different options. If they say something is
impossible, question further. Are they just overwhelmed? Can the problem
be broken down in smaller parts that are more manageable and less
overwhelming? They may have already tried to solve the problem on their
own and know through trial and error that some things really don’t work.
By working together, you not only tighten your bond and understanding, you
also add a level of accountability. They have some ownership of the
solution, and you know what steps to keep an eye out for progress on.
If in these chats you ever suspect your child or teen needs
more help than you can give, never hesitate to seek the help. If you suspect
they are battling depression or other mental health issues, get them connected
to a professional to talk to. Because talk saves lives.
Blissful bonding - chatting, listening, sharing stories, touching base, etc.
“Ugh, I hate when people call me that. That’s not my name.”
For some reason, people think it is ok to be wrong sometimes
. . . all the time. I am guilty of saying, “I am bad with names,” just as much
as the next person, however there is a difference between acknowledging our
weakness – poor short term memory – and just giving up on even trying. I know I
am bad at remembering names after hearing them only once. I am bad at
remembering anything I hear. I know I am not an auditory learner. Over the
years I have had to come up with tricks to try to help me be better. I do not
like not knowing someone’s name. I do not like feeling rude.
That is what it is. It is rude. It is rude to tell someone
his or her individual identity is not important, not worth the effort to
remember. Our names are the most basic outward signs of who we are. They are
our branding, our labels. My first name sets me apart from my three sisters.
Being called Emma rather than “Fox Girl” makes a difference. Am I proud of the
group I belong to? Sure. But I am more proud of the individual I am within that
group. When people ask me, “Which Fox girl are you?” I’m ok with that. That
means they are acknowledging they don’t remember my name, but want to be better
and want to identify me as me. I’d rather answer the question than be called
the wrong name or just called “nameless member of a group”.
For my daughters, they struggle with being called the right
names because in one case people want to presumptively adjust a nickname and in
the other people want to dismiss a name they find too ethnic.
Embracing her namesake.
My older daughter has a hyphenated first name. We were fully
aware when we named her that people would struggle with the hyphen, and we call
her by a nickname – Sofi. For some
reason, though, people take it upon themselves – no matter how much we tell
them what her name is, even spelling it out for them – to call her Sophia. That
is not and has never been her name. I understand Sofi sounds like it could be
short for Sophia, but it isn’t. Once we have said it isn’t, the mistake should
end. The mistake made once is understandable, and we honestly don’t mind the
first time we have to correct a person. HOWEVER if we clearly fill out a form
spelling her name the correct way or if she makes an effort to speak up and
say, “my name is NOT Sophia, so please do not call me that,” then it is rude to
use that as her name. To do so is to say, “Even though you put a lot of thought
into what you named your daughter, and there are many very emotional reasons
for her name being what it is, I am going to decide that MY way of spelling her
name is better and that I know what is the best name for her. Also, I am not
going to listen to her request to be called something else because, again, my
desire to have a name sound and spell the way I am comfortable with it is more
important than her individual identity.” Really. That is what is being said.
Her name is hyphenated because she is also named after this amazing woman - Margaret. Dropping the Margaret hurts.
My younger daughter has a name which is not unheard of in
other parts of the world and is in no way “made up” as people like to ask us.
In the US,
though, it is unusual. Again, we knew when we named her that people would
struggle with it at first, but we liked the name. Considering we are the ones
who say the name the most, really our opinions are the ones that matter most.
Anyway, people had trouble with my name when I was growing up and now it is in
the top 5 most common names in America.
You never know. In the hospital, the woman who came to fill out the form for my
daughter’s birth certificate actually insulted the name and criticized me as a
mother for choosing that name. I pointed out to her that her opinion was
narrow, the name has significance not only culturally but also IT’S NONE OF HER
DAMN BUSINESS WHAT ETHNICITY OUR DAUGHTER’S NAME IS AND WHETHER OR NOT A RANDOM
STRANGER LIKES IT. Since then, most people ask us to say our daughter’s name
twice, then that’s the end of the conversation. They just accept it, call her
by her name, and we all get on with our lives. Most people. About 5% of the
people say, “I can’t say that,” and then give up trying (it is pronounced the
way it is spelled – Yas-ya), make rude comments about ethnic/made up/uncommon
names, or call her Yasha (which is actually a completely different name and is
more commonly used as a nickname for boys translating-ish as Jake). Does this
bother just me as her mom? Nope. Does she notice? Yes. You better believe it.
She has an easy to pronounce third-option-name (Yasya is actually her nickname . .
. her real name is longer and is what the lady in the hospital had a hissy fit
about) which she offers to people she thinks won’t be able to handle her real
name.
Looking up to the man she was named after.
For some reason, the people who can’t pronounce her nickname also tend to
be the ones who think her real name is too intimidating, so they won’t use
that, and they also refuse to call her by her third option name which is super
easy to say. So what is left for her? With that group of 5% she has to deal
with being called the wrong name or no name at all. While other people get
the dignity of an individual identity, she does not. Not because of anything
she has done, but because of that 5%’s comfort level. Have I ever been
uncomfortable saying someone’s name? Sure. But I push myself. I need to be
better. People deserve better.
I am not just being an overly sensitive woman about this and do not need to just get a thicker skin or accept people will be rude or people will change my daughters' names as they see fit. It is rude. Really. Imagine if someone changed your name and
flat out refused to ever spell your name the way you do or call you by the name
you prefer to be called. Would you just shrug that off? Really? Not be even a
little bothered? At the end of the day, this is about dignity on a small scale.
It is about pushing ourselves to do a tiny thing – whether it is easy for us or
not – to recognize people as individual human beings. We look them in the eyes,
we call them by name. Whether we have heard that name before or not. Whether we
would have chosen that name for our child or not. Whether we would use a different nickname or not. Whether that name is from our
ethnic group of not. Because opinions should not affect the amount of basic
respect we show people. We should be better than that. People deserve better.
“Wow, she looks amazing. I hope I look that good some day.”
I see the imperfections; they see the Mama.
“Don’t be silly, Mom. You already look that amazing.”
I love my girls. They are good for my ego (most of the
time). But we do live in a tricky world where figuring out this whole
self-image thing gets pretty complicated really fast and can be devastatingly
destructive. I know it is an issue both males and females battle (my husband
doesn’t go to the gym just because he likes to wake up early and smell other
people’s sweat), but as a female raising females, the female battle is the one
I am more familiar with and the one I have been trying to figure out how to
talk about.
When I was younger, I did the whole mall modeling thing. I
even had an agent. I exercised in my bedroom in the mornings and before bed,
doing sit ups and leg lifts then measuring myself. I always knew my size. I
also always knew every single flaw with my appearance. Eyebrows were waxed and
plucked, skin was inspected for any blemishes, and I would spend hours pacing
back and forth in front of a full length mirror. Then I’d go to school and hear
someone say, “Sure Emma’s pretty, but then she opens her mouth.” Bam! And if
people heard I was modeling, the comments were, “Seriously? Her?” Yeah. Their
skepticism really rammed home my knowledge of my short comings (including my
shortness . . . I’m only 5’8”).
Now as the size 2 mom people love to bash in blogs and
songs, I wish I could say things are better, but people still love to be
snarky. It is up to me to ignore the “skinny bitch” comments I hear from random
strangers when I am shopping (wish I could say I was joking) and in songs
(can’t love “All About That Bass” if it is calling me a bitch because I am not
overweight). It is up to me to hold my head high and not feel responsible for
people obsessing about their thighs just because mine don’t touch. Honestly, I
don’t look at or measure other people’s thighs and didn’t know “thigh gap” was
something to talk about until people started making such a fuss about it on
facebook. I only think about my thigh gap when I drop my phone while I’m on the
toilet. I cannot let other people’s visions of themselves define my vision of
myself.
That is what I try to teach my daughters. They already get
bombarded with pressure to look certain ways. Don’t believe me? Let your second
grader shave her head. Count how many people tell her she is no longer a girl
or no longer pretty or that she is weird, wrong, etc. Let your first grader
wear shoes from the boys’ department. Less extreme action, but she’ll get
similar comments. The pressure to look one way and fit a generic mold of “this
is what little girls are” is intense and destructive. Not every person fits the
same mold and trying to force them to breaks them. As parents, my husband and I decided our goal was to help our girls express themselves and be true to themselves - even if that means coming home from school and shaving their heads in the bathroom then rocking a Star Wars t-shirt and one of my blazers in the pediatrician's office. Looking fierce, Tuna!
My girls and I (and my husband, too!) watch America’s Next
Top Model or Star Trek as our evening tv. These two shows were chosen
intentionally because they help us teach our daughters to be "fierce" and embrace
their differences (and remind us to do the same in our own lives!). Their dad and I can
say over and over, “you are beautiful as is,” but it doesn’t have the same
impact as hearing a super model or star ship captain with perfect hair tell
them that being true to themselves makes them strong and gorgeous.
Here are some of our favorite lessons the girls can take
away from those shows to help them battle the pressures to “look perfect” all
the time:
·Confidence
is Beautiful – The judges on ANTM say this all the time. They send girls
home for not being confident. They tell girls that beauty comes from within and
that they must BELIEVE they are beautiful.
·Compassion is Powerful – This lesson the girls see on both shows. One of their favorite episodes of Star Trek is “Plato’s Stepchildren” because it shows Cpt Kirk and the other crew members showing compassion to a man, Alexander, who had only experienced bullying and abuse before he met them because he didn’t look the same as the other people. Alexander’s transformation is a result of that compassion and helps to defeat the bullies. The compassion was stronger than the hatred showered on him. We talk to the girls not only about the need for them to act as Kirk did to others, but also act that way to themselves. They must show themselves the same compassion.
·Diversity
is Necessary – This is a Star Trek lesson that is evident just by looking
at the make-up of the bridge. The crew comes from all over. Each character
brings different strengths to the table, and Captain Kirk relies on all of them
to help him.
·No One is
Always Perfect Looking – ANTM is great for teaching this lesson. Every girl
has something she doesn’t like about herself, including Tyra Banks. Plus, by
watching old seasons and comparing them to new ones, the girls also see how the
trends change. If a girl from season 20 made herself look and dress exactly
like a girl from season one, she would be outdated and wrong. There is no point
beating ourselves up to fit the idea of perfection of the moment because the
moment changes. Also, the fact that the judges don’t always agree drives home
the message that this idea of perfection is a myth. Perfection is an idea that
varies from person to person, minute to minute. We should not change who we are
or sacrifice ourselves to a false idea.
·Be True
to YOU – Both shows teach this well. Captain Kirk and Tyra Banks in their own
very different ways encourage the people around them to be strong by being true
to themselves. When the girls do that, they can be more confident, embrace
diversity, show compassion to themselves and others, ignore other people’s
definitions of perfection, and – most importantly – be happy.
As Ani Di Franco, my other go-to for shareable wisdom for my
girls, so nicely says, “when you sit right down in the middle of yourself,
you’re gonna want to have a comfortable chair.”
The fairies. Ugh. I wish. I did!!! And why are they acting so shocked? It isn't as if I never clean bathrooms. To be fair, I do clean bathrooms. Regularly. In this case, the shock was because the girls had trashed their bathroom so badly it needed emergency services while they were at school. Lotion on the floor and mirrors, toothpaste all over the sink, nothing where it should be, etc.
Messy desks, but creative kids.
Messes like that are why our home is never 100% in order. And we have messes like that because - ready for a shock? - we have kids! Not only do we have kids, but we have kids who play. I remember explaining this to my husband one day when he was getting cranky about their desks being all kinds of crazy looking and super cluttered. He loves having creative kids who come up with all sorts of original games and projects on their own. The side effect of that is mess. I leave them alone to play and they make messes. Cause and effect.
But I'm a stay-at-home-mom, right? I should be cleaning all day while they are at work and school, right? Yeah . . . no. I mean, I do, but I don't. Here's the reality of being a human today: I have long to-do lists. And I have limits, so one mess gets dealt with while another gets ignored.
Here's a secret - this is true for pretty much ALL moms. Really. I used to feel bad about my cluttered house and how bad it could get on its worst days. Then I talked to my friends. We all have messy house days. We all frantically tidy up before people come over. Even when my best friend is coming over, the one I know won't judge me for my mess, I still hide the bras drying on the door knobs. Do I know she has stacks of laundry waiting to be put away hidden in her house, too? Yup. But we all do it. Every single one of my mom friends has at least one room in her house she considers off limits to guests because that is the "dump everything and close the door" room. Every one has a secret stash of junk stuffed in a drawer or under a couch or chair just hoping no guest finds it. No matter how polished and perfect things look the day you show up, know that every mom is human and therefore spent the last fifteen minutes running around like a chicken with her head cut off frantically stuffing, dusting, vacuuming, and hiding junk.
We all do it because we all have kids making messes and demanding our time and attention. We all have kids who want us to watch them jump off the couch, help them with their homework, feed them, hug them, remind them to brush their teeth (twenty times), tuck them in (thirty times), find their socks, pack their lunches, snuggle on the couch, listen to how their day was, drive them to school, repair their ripped sock alien's antennae (again), etc. So relax. No one is Donna Reed in real life these days and only people who have housekeepers and nannies have homes that are always tidy. Embrace the clutter and know you are not alone.
Every now and then people tell me to not feel guilty about
something or “there’s no shame in that,” and I can’t help looking at them like
they’re a bit off because, honestly, I never thought of feeling guilty or
ashamed of that part of my life. Trust me, there is plenty I don’t like about
myself. I am my harshest critic. But there is also plenty I really don’t worry
about, and I wonder why other people do. Here are a few things I don’t think I
should feel bad about, and I don’t think any other person should, whether they are
happy walrus moms or happy walruses without children or just happy whatevers:
Not being the size of a walrus. I
am skinny. Undoubtedly. My BMI is
right above underweight. There is no denying I am un-walruslike when it
comes to blubber. I simply have none. That’s why I wear multiple sweaters
and shiver a lot. That is also why random strangers call me “skinny bitch”
which I think is really rude. If anyone should be ashamed, it is them.
Rude behavior is bad. Being skinny is not. I used to work with a woman who
literally pinched me on a regular basis and would ask me if I had eaten. I
was always tempted to pinch her back, but I didn’t BECAUSE THAT IS RUDE.
If she is obsessed with my weight, that is her issue, not mine. I don’t
feel guilty about being thinner than her.
Living in an apartment. We own a
house, so this one is weird. When we moved, we didn’t have a ton of time
and didn’t know how permanent our move would be. Renting is the best
option. And I really don’t see a problem with it for us or other families
like ours, yet, for some reason, people have said to me when I tell them
we live in an apartment, “ohhhh, there’s no shame in that.” Huh? Who feels
shame? I like our apartment. It is a heck of a lot easier to maintain than
a house. I don’t have to do yard work for one thing, but the girls get a sweet playground
and tons of kids to play with. And it fits our budget. Why would I feel
ashamed that we made the best decision for our family considering our
current circumstances? A couple years ago, buying a house seemed like the
best choice. Now renting an apartment does. No shame. People are weird.
Having two kids. It seems like no
matter what number of children a person has, there will always be someone
who thinks a different number would be better. For people who know our
family and know the challenges we have faced over the last few years, this
has never been a question. However, there are still people who do ask me
about it and ask why I didn’t welcome more lives into our family. This is
a personal issue and really people should back off. Do I feel bad that I
didn’t have more? No. I know why we have two and that is all that matters.
Sewing and cooking and being a
stay-at-home-mom. Really, people? You want me to feel guilty about cooking
dinner now? Blarg. I was raised by a couple of feminists, so the thought
of being anything other than a feminist is just super foreign to me. When
people tell me I am anti-feminist and ask me if I feel bad about setting a
bad example for my daughters by being "a little wifey", I don’t feel bad for
me, but I do feel bad for them. And I kind of want to punch them. But I
don’t. Because that would be rude. If you have never watched the series
Makers on PBS, I recommend it. It shows the history of the feminist
movement in an interesting way including the choices women now face between full time work and being a stay-at-home-mom. Being
a stay-at-home-mom is a choice. It doesn’t mean rejecting female
education, opportunity, employment, or any other form of equality. I sew
because I enjoy it. I cook because it is the most cost effective way to
get food into my children. I am a stay-at-home-mom because I am raising my
children and for our family having me home is the best way to get that job
done. And I like it. My daughters know and understand all that. So to the
people who look at me with their judgey eyes, I look right back with my confident
eyes. I know all the reasons I am here, and I stand firmly behind my
choice and do not feel bad. Plus I have awesome kids who eat salads. So
pht. (OK, so that last part was a little rude.)
The sad truth is that no matter what kinds of walruses we are,
there will always be someone who thinks we should be a seagull. What I try to
teach my girls is to be confident in their decisions. No one else will know all
the details that go into their decision making processes. People just see the
end results. The girls need to stand by their choices and not feel they have to
explain them to others or be ashamed of who they are, where they live, how many
kids they do or do not have, or how they spend their time (as long as they
aren’t breaking any laws or being rude going around pinching skinny people).
They will much happier if they can stand up and say, “this is me and I’m ok
with that.” As the saying goes, “the best accessory is
confidence.”
I recently went to the girls’ school and got to chat with
their teachers a bit. My younger daughter’s teacher said that periodically my
daughter will claim, “I’m Ukrainian; I can’t remember that!” Her teacher wanted
to know why Ukrainians can’t remember things. I nearly fell over laughing and
pointed out my daughter is only PART Ukrainian, so that’s a BS excuse (and
Ukrainians aren’t known for memory isssues, so really it’s a double BS excuse).
The truth is only her father is Ukrainian. I’m something else entirely. And
even her Ukrainian father considers himself to be a mix of things. To keep
things simple, we call ourselves American and Ukrainian, but if we move beyond
where we were born, then things get more complicated. So how do we define what
we are and why does it matter?
Both my husband and I have traced our families back many
generations, and we are both very proud of our family histories. We love the
mix we have. On both sides we have people who were adventurous, crossing
borders, marrying into new traditions, learning new languages, and taking on
challenges that make anything I’ve ever faced seem like nothing. Our mixed up
family trees make answering the question, “what are you?” a little complicated
and long winded sometimes, but it makes parenting so much richer. As long as
people accept the answer of “American and Ukrainian” or “well, mostly
Irish-Polish-American and Ukrainian” then we’re fine. At home, the girls get
the full stories, though.
My father’s family has been in what is now the US since the early 1700s and originally came
from Wales,
however almost every generation has married an immigrant. What can I say? We
like accents. The stories of my ancestors on my father’s side are wonderful for
inspiring the girls when they find themselves uncomfortable in new situations.
I remind them of my great-grandmother who came to America from Poland as a
young teen, without her parents, riding on top of her trunk in steerage because
she was too poor to afford a real ticket, and started a new life in a new
county and had to learn a new language. And she did it. We have stories of my
great-grandfather who traveled from Vilnius, Lithuania, to Lviv,
Ukraine, to St.
Petersburg, Russia,
to Poland before moving to America and settling in Chicago. Or my grandmother who went back to Poland so she could receive the best music
education studying piano in Warsaw
just before World War II. The girls ancestors through my father were brave,
going where they needed to go to have the best lives they could. Fear didn’t
hold them back. That’s a pretty nice lesson for the girls. Plus, they picked up
great food traditions along the way. I mean, is there any better food in the
world than Polish food? Seriously. It’s the best.
My grandmother on my mother's side.
My mother’s family is proud Chicago-Irish. I have come to
the conclusion there is nothing stronger than a Chicago-Irish woman. My grandmother, mother, and aunts are the iron women who could bend Wonder Woman in half. I have never doubted their awesomeness, and they set a very high bar of excellence and inner strength. My mom’s family began coming to America in the 1850s from Ireland and continued to come in waves until just before 1900 including one young man who stepped off the boat and right into the Union army during the Civil War. They were all poor and mostly illiterate according to census records until my grand-parents’ generation. The census records are depressing. They show that often as many as three quarters of each generation would die before reaching their teenage years. While the women were burying their babies, the men were literally building Chicago. Growing up, I used to love walking
around the city with my mom who would proudly say, “my family built that
bridge.” My mom’s family survived because they worked hard. They didn’t give
up. When the girls want to quit because they think a task is too difficult, I
remind them of their Chicago-Irish blood. If their ancestors had given up,
people wouldn’t be able to cross the Chicago River.
The McLennons didn’t give up, and the girls won’t either.
On Saturdays, the girls go to Ukrainian school to learn
Ukrainian and celebrate their father’s side. Part of it. He reminds them his
grandfather identified as Polish (again, EXCELLENT food traditions) and tells
them the more complex stories of his family. Yes, he was born and raised in Ukraine, but
his Ukrainian family history is just as rich as my American family history. He
has heroes whose stories culminated with him being born in Kyiv which are the
things of legends. They lived through countless wars and famines, slept in
cemeteries, and spoke more than one language. When he tells them he is
Ukrainian, that is just the first sentence in a long book.
Looking back at our families and where we have come from
makes our lives so much richer. It gives us a plethora of stories to tell our
girls at bedtime. We can draw from more than just our own experiences to teach
them and inspire them. I am proud to be more than just one thing, and I am so
happy I continued my family tradition of marrying a hot immigrant with an
adorable accent. I hope our girls remember these stories and continue to tell
them. And eat Polish food. Because it is good. And that can't be said enough.
Sure fire way to piss me off is to start talking about
whether or not my kids are Ukrainian enough. I hate that. I hate the whole idea
of measuring someone’s ethnicity in general, but this particular term really
irks me. For one thing, it is usually applied in an inconsistent way. Usually
the person who is telling me – the non-Ukrainian parent – what is or is not
Ukrainian enough is wrong herself and is basing her ideas about Ukrainian-ness
on her experience growing up in the diaspora. Example: “REAL Ukrainians don’t
put ketchup on holubtsi.” This is a pretty undisputed fact within the diaspora,
however in modern Ukraine
ketchup is common and is put on a lot of foods including sometimes holubtsi. I've witnessed it first hand and don't understand why it is a big deal to say it happens. The problem
for me with the “Ukrainian enough” statement is two pronged. First, I don’t
want anyone narrowly defining my kids. Second, their criteria are outdated and
inaccurate to begin with.
Learning through experience, walking around
Chernivtsi, Ukraine with her dad's cousin and friend.
What do we do instead of throwing varenyky at people who say
stuff like that to us? We hug our daughters and make a big fuss about how
wonderful MY side of the family is. We on my side aren’t Ukrainian at all, but we’re still
pretty dang fantastic. Then my husband teaches them how to speak and read Ukrainian.
Disney princesses speak Ukrainian, too (we get our movies from Ukraine). We
decorate our home with a mix of the different cultures – Ukrainian, Polish,
Irish, and anything else we like. And most importantly we take the girls
physically to Ukraine.
The REAL Ukraine.
The best way for them to know what real Ukrainians do and do not do is for them
to go there and spend time just hanging out with Ukrainians. I’m not going to
tell my girls that Ukrainians don’t eat ketchup because I know they do.
Ukrainians are modern people who like foods that taste yummy. They also watch
tv and drive cars and wear tennis shoes. They aren’t all named Tanya and Taras.
They give their kids names they like which are sometimes traditional Slavic
names and sometimes they aren’t. They listen to rap music and pop music and
sometimes traditional folk music. They don’t all drink horilka or wear head
scarves. They are a variety of religions with a variety of political view
points. Some like the west and some like the east and some don’t have an
opinion (just like Americans!). Not everyone owns an embroidered shirt, and there
are people in Adidas who love their country even more than the most
embroidered, blue-and-yellow-ed, flower wreathed person you can find. Learning the old traditions is great, but it doesn't define being Ukrainian any more than apple pie and baseball define being American.
That is what we want our girls to know and understand. Being
proud of Ukraine and being
proud of America
don’t mean fitting in one tiny cubby. Both are great countries with many
wonderful traditions, and both are dynamic countries which are growing and
changing with the times. The people are adapting and eating ketchup in both
places, and that’s fine. As long as they don’t get it on their hot dogs. That’s
just not Chicagoan enough. ;)
a mix - Irish shepherd's pie with Ukrainian insignia and curry seasoning
I love when the tables turn and my girls pat my hand and ask
me how my day was. They are so fascinated that I have a life sometimes. Since
we moved states, that table turning has been spinning so much we have equalized
a bit which is nice. It gives me some credibility when I tell them to get out
there and make friends if they see that I have to do the same. For them,
getting out there means school and sports. For me, it means chatting with the
other parents at their schools and sports. And volunteering.
I was raised to see volunteering as something we just do.
Like eating or sleeping or brushing our teeth. If I can help, I should simply
because that is the decent human thing to do. All of the grown-ups I knew,
whether they were working full-time jobs or not, whether they got recognition
for their service or not, simply volunteered when they could. It was never a
big deal, never about pressure or for show. As a mom, though, I see that not
everyone else views it that way. And it is a bit of a crazy world.
When I was a working mom, I felt a TON of pressure to
volunteer more. I felt I had to prove I was still an involved parent. Who I
thought I had to prove this to, I’m not sure. Maybe the random haters who would
talk loudly at the other tables in the lunch room about “the trouble with
parents these days is that they work too much and leave their kids to be raised
by strangers” (even though it was my father who was doing the bulk of the
daycare, so I really should have shrugged that off)? Maybe it was the other
parents at the preschool who would brag about knowing all the teachers on a
first name basis (even though my mom was a teacher there so technically I knew
them all, too, and should have shrugged that one off as well)? Who knows. But I
felt like I had to be doing more. Which was dumb. All I had to be doing was
loving my kids and taking care of them. Screw what the other parents thought
about me.
As a SAHM, I know I could feel pressure to out perform the
other SAHMs, but I’m not going to. I’ve grown-up a bit. Sure, I still care what
people think of me. I just don’t let it totally rule me (and never totally did
. . . I did say no to a lot of volunteering even as a working mom – I just felt
bad about it then and don’t feel bad about it now). I am meeting new groups of
moms these days and keep getting the same advice: don’t over-volunteer. Great
advice. But my mom already gave me that advice many years ago which is why even
when I did feel pressured to do so, I didn’t give in. My mom said pick one or two areas to volunteer in and stick to those. Being helpful means not being exhausted or resentful. It means not burning the candle at both ends.
my mom's advice, but in Ron Swanson's words (from here)
And when
I feel I have too much on my plate or my health is bad or my back hurts too
much, IT IS OK TO SAY NO. Taking care of my health and my family comes first.
If I don’t do that, then someone else would have to. I smile at the moms who
tell me not to over-volunteer, then listen to them tell me how over-involved
they are. I know they are talking more to themselves than to me. They don’t
know me, so they don’t know that I will certainly NOT be leading a garden club
ever nor will I ever take over as treasurer of anything simply because I feel
like I ought to. I don’t think I owe it to the working mothers to “pick up
their slack” by volunteering twice as much (that just insults working mothers
who I really don’t think need extra insults). I don’t think I need to have
something scheduled for every day. I don’t think it is my duty to put in
community service hours because I am not bringing in a paycheck. Nope.
my NO face....it gets used plenty
I
volunteer when an opportunity comes up that I think fits me. Something I think
I can do well. Like teaching catechism classes. Or working at the book fair. Or
being a hall monitor. And recently I have been volunteering to meet new people
and make new friends here in our new state.
If they are going to use my volunteerism as a yardstick, however, for my
goodness as a mom, I’ll pass. I think we should all be old enough now to stop
judging each other like that and just be moms together, regardless of how many
volunteer hours we’re logging. Can’t we just focus on what really matters?
Who’s bringing the coffee to the next meeting?!?!?!
OK, today I am not arguing this one. Today I am saying, yes,
when people say this one particular thing to me, I get really irked. As I’ve
said before (in a lovely blog here), I’m not naturally a super bubbly people person.
I would rather be home alone with my books and skulls and bats and stuffed
walruses. I do try to be more patient and understanding and outgoing, though. I
do try to reach out to people and engage in the world around me. Most of the
time, it works and I find that “fake it till you make it” works. Most but not
all of the time.
How I feel some days. Just go away, people.
I know that for a lot of moms the real “I’m gonna punch you
in the teeth” question is the “what do you do all day” question. Yeah, that one
can be annoying, but I really don’t think the question itself is the problem.
As a former working mom turned stay-at-home mom, I get it. I used to wonder
what SAHMs did, too. I wasn’t being judgey. I was curious. And I think most of
the people who ask me are curious, too. There are judgey people, but the
question itself isn’t inherently judgey.
No, the thing that gets me riled up and has me grinding my
teeth and doing mental back flips trying to come up with justifications for
people saying crap like that is when people say to me, “well, you’re just lucky your kids were born so well behaved.” Um,
no, they weren’t. Before I get into why this annoys me (acknowledging upfront
that I might be overreacting, but whatever, I’m allowed to considering I don’t
actually in real life flip out at people so how much am I really over
reacting?), here are my rationales I run through in my head to stop me from
saying mean things back to people:
The
people are just trying to say my kids are not being poop heads. That’s a
good thing. Take the compliment and run. Really. Just run. Don’t open your
mouth.
Most
parents are insecure about their parenting abilities and try to find ways
of justifying what they see as failures on their parts. Saying someone
else’s kid was born that way just takes a little of the burden off them
and makes them feel better. Let them feel better and run. Don’t open your
mouth.
People
get mixed up about nature vs nurture and think it is an either/or thing.
Explaining the way brains are wired and how we are socialized and the way
we are a balance of inherited traits and learned behaviors takes too long.
Just run. Don’t open your mouth.
Maybe
they know I’m part Irish and eat way too much Lucky Charms? Who knows . .
. now I’m grasping at straws. Just run. Don’t open your mouth. Unless it
is to eat Lucky Charms.
Here is why that bugs me. I work really hard. Really. My
kids, like all kids, were born as little screaming babies. Well, one was. The
other wasn’t screaming because she couldn’t breath. But eventually she was a
screaming baby. Point is they were not born preprogrammed to obey their
teachers, raise their hands in class, do their homework every day, follow
rules, respect authority figures, say please and thank you, not hit kids when
they don’t get their way, etc. My husband and I make very deliberate decisions
with our children (I talk about that more here) and work very hard to teach them how to behave. Can we
control them? No. But we can try to instill morals and values and guide them.
Are our girls perfect? Heck no! Do they have challenges? Oh, YES! Just because
people don’t see the challenges doesn’t mean they aren’t there. We have had
many epic battles with the girls at home. We have questioned our parenting and
wondered if our kids will in fact grow up to be international criminal
masterminds (even if they turn out evil, we expect them to do well). We have
had sleepless nights worrying about our kids and wondering what to do. When we
get to those bridges we can’t cross on our own, we get outside help which for
our younger daughter has meant speech therapy and help with anxiety.
"She reads? You're so lucky." No, I had to fight and have
MANY conversations to find the right kind of books for her
to read and the right kind of motivation to get her to read.
It wasn't luck; it was determination.
Each
girl has a different personality and different needs to be addressed. That is
true for every child. Every parent takes the child they have and tries to
parent the best they can to meet that child’s needs. For us, as we go along and
learn we have had to adapt our parent strategies to fit the needs of our two
very different children. This means swallowing our pride, researching parenting
techniques, talking to specialists, meeting with teachers, spending countless
hours listening to our daughters and trying to figure out strategies for
success with them, explaining why punching annoying people in the face really
isn’t a good solution (no matter how tempting it is). In short, we work HARD to
have good kids. Our kids are physically healthy at this point, and that is
partly luck (and partly careful parenting again), but that is where the luck
stops.
I’m not saying we work harder than other parents, but I am
saying we do work. Calling our kids’ good behavior “luck” ignores our hard
work. It diminishes the effort and careful consideration we put into every day.
I know sometimes parents say it because they are defensive about their own kids
and parenting, but honestly most of the time I am more focused on my kids and
wouldn’t have noticed their kids till they made that comment. Calling my
parenting “luck” makes me think, “you think parenting is about luck not work?
What are you doing with your kid? Sitting back hoping to get lucky and have him
figure out on his own that he shouldn’t push my kid? No wonder he is acting
that way.” And that is when I do get judgey. And I don’t like feeling judgey.
And I don’t want other moms to feel judged. Being a mom is – or at least should
be – hard enough.
Spending time with our girls, talking to them, trying to understand them
so we can guide them the best. No luck involved here. Just lots of time.
So if you come across some really well behaved kids who are
eating a salad and not throwing knives at people, don’t be mean to the parents
or snarky by calling them “lucky” or worse yet making a sarcastic comment
mocking them. Either say nothing or just say, “what a nice kid.” Because
chances are the parents had many battles at home before the kid would eat that
salad in public.
my Righteous Babe in her fave "someone call the girl police" shirt
This seems to be a constant source of annoyance for my older
daughter and her personal mission in life. We have nicknamed her our Gender
Equality Warrior Princess. Ever since kids started teasing her about her
running shoes when she was in first grade (story here), she has been painfully aware of
gender stereotypes in this country and the limitations they try to put on
people. It bugs her. I am bugged, too. Her dad is, too.
She made this shirt herself to spread her
gender equality message.
There are a lot of problems when it comes to gender
inequality and gender stereotyping. They
range from day to day little things that the girls face in school to larger
problems that adult men and women have to deal with in jobs, politics, and
health. How we are treated and how we are expected to behave are still defined
by gender. For my older daughter, that becomes an annoying problem because she
wants to think and act beyond those boundaries. She wants to make decisions for
herself based on her own personality and preferences and does not think she
should be limited by something as arbitrary as gender.
For the last three years, she has been coming to terms with
how her classmates want her to behave and accepting that when she follows her
heart, they won’t always approve of it. We have a saying in our house: “Not
everyone likes broccoli.” Every person has different tastes and won’t like the
same things. We can’t change our tastes to suit the tastes of the people around
us, and we can’t expect them to change their tastes to suit ours. It is not
always an easy thing to do, being true to herself in the face of snarky girls
who mock her for not wearing nail polish or sparkly clothes, but she perseveres.
For her father, the journey to feminism was a bit different.
He thought he was a feminist until he had daughters and a wife. Then the tiny
little prejudices started showing. They seep in because they are such a strong
part of culture. It is hard to avoid absorbing some assumptions of who should
do what or who is capable of doing what. He has grown to be a gender equality
warrior along with his daughter, and I think, like my own dad, it isn’t because
he is the father of girls, but simply because he is a father. He doesn’t care about gender equality because he is a feminist
in the sense that he thinks females need to be defended but in the sense that
he loves his children and wants them to have access to all their dreams and to
be free to be themselves. If we had sons instead of daughters, he would want
the same for them. He is a feminist in the sense that he wants all people to
live to their full potentials.
That is why I am so excited about Emma Watson’s speech to
the UN. For my Gender Equality Warrior Princess, seeing Hermione standing up -
her voice shaking, but still speaking up - telling the world to look at gender,
“as a spectrum, instead of two sets of opposing ideals,” is powerful. It is
empowering. It is reassuring. It is telling my daughter she has been right all
along and she is not alone. It is saying, “you can like fairies and hockey, and
that’s ok, and I stand with you.” It is also supporting their dad. It tells him
his role as a father is valuable, and his emotions are valuable. It tells him,
“you can love your daughters just as much as your wife does, and that’s ok, and
I stand with you.”
I love that speech, and I love the He For She campaign. I hope it
reaches many people, but even if it doesn’t, it will reach my daughter and help
her. And as a mom, that makes me happy.